But the Earth still warms

Political activists who oppose working to stop or slow greenhouse gas emissions in order to slow global warming find themselves in awkward positions recently.

Before, during and after the Copenhagen meeting in December 2009 they predicted that warming had stopped, and that we are entering a period of global cooling.  Alas for their claim, the planet refuses to cool.  The decade ending in 2009 was the warmest in human history; 2010 itself turned out to be one of the warmest years in history, worldwide.

NOAA graphic: Indicators of global warming: “Seven of these indicators would be expected to increase in a warming world, and observations show that they are, in fact, increasing. Three would be expected to decrease and they are, in fact, decreasing.”

Somebody stole hundreds of e-mails from one of the climate research clusters in England, and the anti-action activists claimed that the messages would reveal wrong-doing on the part of scientists, perhaps even criminal action.  Instead, five separate investigations discovered no wrong-doing on the parts of scientists, but a lot of hard work gone for too little action because of the anti-science shenanigans of the anti-action crew.  The science showing global warming remains untouched, with no significant body of research showing contrary.

One of the loudest voices against claims of global warming, Christopher Monckton, was unmasked as a blowhard and a fraud.    Scientists organized to refute the hoax claims of the anti-action activists.

So, the anti-action activists are sore.  They don’t take criticism well, and they especially don’t like anyone who points out their errors.

Sadly, they didn’t learn from the their past hoaxes.  So if even a lowly high school teacher should point out an error of history, they resort to making false claims and censorship against the teacher.  They have no data to back their case, nothing but invective to rebut with.

And so it was that a rather new site, hauntingthelibrary, took my comment noting where they could find the data to disabuse their wild claims, stripped it out, and substituted words I did not and would not write.

Fraud again, this time from hauntingthelibraryHoaxFraud even in small things.

The movement against the science of global warming is rotten to its core.  (Seriously — most sites would be happy to note the pingback from this blog; the blogger had to act to block the pingback from showing up.  What are they so afraid of?)

Legend says that Galileo, backing out of the audience with the Pope in which he was put under house arrest after having “recanted” any claim that the Earth orbits the Sun, said quietly, “Still, it moves.”  Even the Pope’s powers through the Inquisition could not stop the Earth orbiting the Sun.  No matter how powerful the denial propaganda machines, no matter how many anti-science bloggers they recruit, the Earth keeps on stubbornly warming up.

Or, as Galileo might have said, “Eppure, lei si scalda!”


Update: Then there is Anti-Gore Effect Sillies Syndrome — claiming Gore erred, when he didn’t.  It’s demonstrated with the infection fully affecting the judgment of its victims at this odd place, XD Talk Forums.



Earlier at Millard Fillmore’s Bathtub:

Photo by W. W. MacFarlane - Pine bark beetle damage in Teton National Forest

Photo by W. W. MacFarlane – NPR caption: “Many dead trees appear gray and red on the high-mountain slopes of Union Pass Bridger in Teton National Forest in Wyoming”

14 Responses to But the Earth still warms

  1. […] While denialists rage, the Earth still warms. Eppure, lei si scalda. […]


  2. Ed Darrell says:

    See pine bark beetle problems here:


  3. Ed Darrell says:

    Still solid science, Mr. Fisher. I note you offer no rebuttal.

    Were it true that #GlobalWarming is not being observed in these ten indicators, surely you could produce a trove of research showing your point.

    You offer nothing.


  4. Mark Fisher says:

    Denunciations are poor substitutes for rational argument. This is a screed from someone offended that his arguments have been dismissed. Climate fluctuation is natural, cyclical & human influence so minor as to defy measurement.


  5. Ed Darrell says:

    You may, perhaps, be able to copy this comment, and thereby copy the image, to embed in comments in other WordPress blogs.

    I hope so.


  6. […] “But the Earth still warms” (Millard Fillmore’s Bathtub) […]


  7. […] Earlier we discussed the political jabs lacking scientific merit at the blogs that have sprung up to harry and heckle climate scientists, especially a relatively new one called, inaptly, “haunting the library.” […]


  8. Ed Darrell says:

    I don’t think anyone believes Galileo made any smart-donkey comments in leaving the presence of the Pope and the Inquisition.

    But the statement attributed to him is true, and so it clings. King Canute at least understood that he could not control the tides. The hubris of the Inquisition to think they could control the orbits of the planets stands is sharp contrast.


  9. george.w says:

    Does anyone think the Galileo legend is literally true? In any case it is certainly a fine parable about the stubbornness of reality against our preferences.

    Eventually the climate picture will be clear to everyone. We can all muse about what things would have been like had we done something about it, while there was still time.


  10. I *don’t*… Preview is fun, but proof reading has to be considered a useful substitute, I guess.

    BTW, the Galileo quote is an odd one, since the story around it is unclear, and in its purest form, rather impossible. In the offices of the Inquisition, having just formally recanted on a point of “vehement suspicion of heresy”, he’s gonna stamp his foot and say “But it does move”? Not if he doesn’t want a fast-track pass to the stake. And who would have reported this, anyway? A sympathetic inquisitor who overheard it? So it’s usually dismissed in modern times as a fabrication from a century later.

    This also is wrong. The phrase was discovered (a hundred years ago!) in a painting of Galileo made in the 1640s. So the *story* existed then, and circumstances make it likely that it’s based on real event, but it didn’t happen as in the standard story.

    But on topic: The press releases about the official temperatures for 2010 had one point buried well enough that it ended up in the virtual lead-pots of papers that follow the rule “All the news that fits, we print.” The point leads to a possible bar bet as follows:

    The average temperature for any year will be above the long-term average some years, and below it in others. That’s what the talk of random fluctuations means. So, how many years in this century have had an average temperature *lower* than the average for the whole 20th century?

    No, it’s not a trick question about centuries: leave 2000 out or in, no difference.

    Because the answer is zero. None. Naught. Nil. Nada. Odds against such a sequence if it came by random yearly fluctuations: 1,000 to 1 and then some.

    However, the actual string of temperatures above the 20th-century average is slightly longer. My recollection involves 1985 or so, but I haven’t time to look it up now. But who cares about million-to-one odds anyway?


  11. @John Mashey:
    Not sure what this means. In point 1, which evidence is this? The trend of local temperatures in their part of British Columbia? Or are they in correspondence with lumberjacks, shepherds, rice paddy workers, and camel drivers around the world?

    I don’e quite understand 2; and 3 is, I suppose reassuring if the reference is to skill with graphical representations.


  12. John Mashey says:

    Since we’re up in B.C. every year, I’ve sat with lumber guys in ski lodges. People could tell them it’s all in their imagination, but I wouldn’t advise it:

    1) They see the evidence around them.
    2) Even ex-lumberjacks tend towards begin big.
    3) And I think they still know how to use axes.


  13. […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Tony Sidaway. Tony Sidaway said: But the Earth still warms http://dlvr.it/DZTMk […]


  14. Ellie says:

    They just have no shame at all about lying, do they? And they aren’t even Lying For Jesus.


Please play nice in the Bathtub -- splash no soap in anyone's eyes. While your e-mail will not show with comments, note that it is our policy not to allow false e-mail addresses. Comments with non-working e-mail addresses may be deleted.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: