Tricks to deal with dementia: Give them a clue – lie if necessary

If your family has not been touched by a member with Alzheimer’s Disease, senile dementia, or some other form of memory-killing disease, you’re in a lucky minority.

A good friend told how her brother-in-law eased the pain of her mother’s slide into dementia, with little lies. The mother developed an invisible friend who had to accompany her on most outings. The problem was that the invisible friend was also invisible to the mother. The brother-in-law, frustrated at the mother’s refusal leave her room for an outing because the friend was not apparent to accompany them, finally told the mother that the friend was already in the car. Mom happily scooted to the car and forgot about the friend completely by the time they got to the car.

The friend was “already there” for much of the rest of the mother’s life. It was a lie, a falsehood, but it made things so much easier.

CBS Evening News tonight featured a story on a potential new treatment for dementia. In one segment, a husband was quizzing his dementia-affected wife, and she could not recall what he had told her just a few minutes before, how many years they had been married. Frustrating for the victim as well as the family.

Vodpod videos no longer available.

more about “CBS report on Alzheimers“, posted with vodpod

A British psychologist, Oliver James, has a new book out that suggests such quizzes do more damage, and are unnecessary. Help the victim along with cues, he says. It’s a trick he got from his own mother-in-law, Penny Garner, from her experience working with her mother.

In Dorothy’s case, Garner found that while she [Dorothy] had no idea what she had done moments before, she automatically tried to make sense of her situation by matching it to past experiences. Dorothy had always enjoyed travelling, and so if she was asked to sit with other people for any length of time, she assumed she was in the Heathrow departure lounge. By not challenging this assumption, Garner found that her mother would sit peacefully for long periods. If she did wander off, Garner found she could encourage her to return by reminding her of her former skill as a bridge-player, telling her that the other players were waiting for her. “Given a properly set up bridge table, my mother would spend hours happily looking at her cards and waiting to play,” she says.

People with dementia are often exhausting to care for because they forget what they are doing during routine activities. Garner found that she could enable her mother to remain relatively independent by providing cues. “If while getting ready for bed, I noticed she had lost track of whether she was buttoning up the cardigan ready to go out or taking it off to go to bed, I would fiddle with my buttons alongside her and say ‘Oh good! No more travelling for us today! Glad we’ve got a bed for the night!’ I found that this simple cue was all she needed. Without it, she was inclined to get half-way through undressing and then start getting dressed again.”

We all look for such cues in everyday life, and we use them to remind us of what we are doing, where we are going, and why. Why not make it easier for victims of dementia?

Who is president of the United States? Half the time I’d prefer to forget it’s George W. Bush. Don’t quiz me on it. Ask me if it isn’t great that we’re electing someone to replace him, this fall.

Smart human tricks.


4 Responses to Tricks to deal with dementia: Give them a clue – lie if necessary

  1. Ed Darrell says:

    Working out very well. The 110-year effort to get a national health care plan finally got some action, a good first step to providing Americans with the high quality health care they deserve and the best quality of health care in the world.

    Republicans complained, but the Obama stimulus package went beyond just bailing out banks to push the economy back near to where it needs to be to create growth. We nearly lost America, but Obama’s team saved it so far.

    Obama’s education team brought student loans in-house, where the Department of Education has, for years, been more effective and dramatically more efficient in parceling out student loans, and collecting on them. This is part of a major effort to make college affordable to more American kids — things that people knew we should have done years ago, but just didn’t.

    You can read about that and some other achievements, here:

    Unlike the previous few presidents, Obama appears to have noted down the promises he made on the campaign trail and tried to live up to most of them. Media Matters found 91 promises Obama had kept by January (see the story here: )

    I’m happy with the Lily Ledbetter Act. I’m pleased with the attempt to return sanity to the Supreme Court in the very capable personage of Sonia Sotomayor. The change in EPA regulations to rein in air pollution from superships was long overdue, and a major boon to ending greenhouse gas emissions.

    I think in almost every area, the nation and the world can breathe — or has already breathed — a sign of relief that a smart, capable, politically and truth-astute person now occupies the White House.

    It’s great that we replaced Bush, and it’s fantastically wonderful that Obama was the guy we replaced him with. Our most recent long national nightmare has ended, and it’s morning in America once again. Hope brought about change, and we can be hopeful about America’s future once again.

    Better than that Palin, bad community college, small town, high emo-low intellectual content lingo is working for you.


  2. Sal says:

    Who is president of the United States? Half the time I’d prefer to forget it’s George W. Bush. Don’t quiz me on it. Ask me if it isn’t great that we’re electing someone to replace him, this fall.
    How’s that hopey, changey stuff workin’ out for ya?


  3. […] Darrell at Millard Filmore’s Bathtub has an interesting post which discusses tips for helping loved ones who suffer from Alzheimer’s Disease and other forms of dementia. He also has a rather disturbing post about the perils of teaching evolution. I admit to only […]


  4. […] from Millard Fillmore’s Bathtub, with […]


Please play nice in the Bathtub -- splash no soap in anyone's eyes. While your e-mail will not show with comments, note that it is our policy not to allow false e-mail addresses. Comments with non-working e-mail addresses may be deleted.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: