Dan Bates served on the staff at Camp Maple Dell for at least the part of one summer when I was on junior staff there, in Utah’s Payson Canyon (1969? 1970?). Maple Dell is a Boy Scout camp operated by the Utah National Parks Council, B.S.A.
I remember Dan because he was one of those overachieving guys who had earned every possible merit badge — 121 at the time, if I recall correctly. By comparison, there are 21 merit badges necessary to earn Eagle Scout (which Dan is, also).
It didn’t go to his head at all. Dan was a great guy, from Heber, Utah, a small town up Provo Canyon in one of the world’s most beautiful valleys. Heber used to be separated from much of Utah by snow every year, but the roads are kept clear these days.
Once I asked Dan what possessed him to get every merit badge, and without pausing long, he said, “What else do you do in Heber in the winter?” It was a flip answer unexpected from the usually more sober Bates.
I think about Dan this time of year when the news stories start appearing about a new Scout, somewhere, who has earned every merit badge. One of the common themes of these stories: Has anyone else ever done it?
Eagle Scout Travis Cochran, California, holder of every merit badge
In The Press-Enterprise in San Bernardino, County, California, for example, the June 25 issue reports the achievements of Travis Cochran:
If Don Townsend was a betting man he’d put money on the fact that Travis Cochran is the only Boy Scout to have earned every merit badge and the Bronze and Silver Hornaday Medals.
Cochran, 18, of Cedarpines Park, earned 122 merit badges during his scouting career. Twenty-one merit badges must be earned to reach the rank of Eagle Scout.
There is a qualification in this story — Cochran also earned the Bronze and Silver Hornaday Conservation Medals — but you see the drift.
Alas, there is no central location for information about such achievements that I have ever found. Tracking the achievements of Boy Scouts, like the tremendous accomplishments of Scouts Dan Bates and Travis Cochran, generally falls to the local unit. Sometimes a local Boy Scout Council will have some information, but usually not.
History sneaks away so often because no one bothers to invite it to stick around.
Do you know of other Boy Scouts who earned every possible merit badge? We had one such Scout in the Circle 10 Council (Dallas) last year. How many others sneaked by without the hoopla they deserve?
Dan Bates, where are you these days?
Update, August 2009: Dan Bates has been found!
Dan wrote in from Mesa, Arizona, and the Grand Canyon Council — see his note in comments, below. Turns out I remembered it incorrectly — he had 100 merit badges, but not all of them. His brother got them all. Glad for the correction. Happier to have found Mr. Bates.
Other resources:
- 2007 Washington Post story on James Calderwood, Chevy Chase, Maryland, “Scout Soars Far Beyond Eagle”
- 2007 stories in Salt Lake City’s Deseret News, on Alex Recksieck, Dallin Manning, and Parker Duncan
- 2006 story in The Kansas City Star, on Austin Marlin, mentioning Jared Thatcher
- Unnamed father-son team from Erie Shores Council
- 2006 story in The Boston Globe, on Chris Talutis, of Milton, Massachusetts
- Added 8-2-2008: Roland Salatino, Troop 577, Dallas, Texas
- Added 12-30-2008: Shawn Goldsmith, Troop 240, Bronx, New York
- Added 1-3-2008: Raymond Adrian DeLeon, Jr., Venture Crew 1209, Austin, Texas
- Added 10-9-2009: Cameron Barber, Dallas, in 2007
- Please look for other stories in this series at Millard Fillmore’s Bathtub, listed in the category of “121 Merit Badge Club”
[Do you like stories about good kids, like these Boy Scouts? Click the Digg button, above — or one of the other buttons below!]
Posted by Ed Darrell 
Millard Fillmore's Bathtub 