For science, Bing loses badly to Google; not safe for school kids?

June 24, 2009

Have you tried Bing yet?

Nice pictures — the wallpaper is cooler than Google’s rather sterile white background.  I’m not much fond of the way Bing shows images, with some down the side when you check out another, but without any identifying data to help you figure out which ones to check out.

But I stumbled into a major problem:  At least on DDT, Bing favors the Tinfoil Hat Brigades™, featuring crank science almost exclusively on the first page in my early searches, compared to Google’s pointing first to the hard science.

Importantly, this tells me that Bing is not safe to assign to students doing research.

Bing will bear watching all summer.  Can they get it up to speed by the opening of schools in the fall?

Here’s the Google web search for “ddt”:

  1. DDT – Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

    – 2 visits – May 27

    DDT (from its trivial name, dichlorodiphenyltrichloroethane) is one of the most well-known synthetic pesticides. It is a chemical with a long, unique,
    en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DDTCachedSimilar

  2. DDT, What is DDT? About its Science, Chemistry and Structure

    Find out about the science and chemistry of DDT (Banned Insecticide), see colourful images of DDT and explore interactive 3D molecules of DDT.
    http://www.3dchem.com/molecules.asp?ID=90CachedSimilar

  3. DDT Ban Takes Effect | EPA History | US EPA

    – Jun 17

    The general use of the pesticide DDT will no longer be legal in the United States after today, ending nearly three decades of application during which time
    http://www.epa.gov/history/topics/ddt/01.htm – CachedSimilar

  4. DDT |Persistent Bioaccumulative and Toxic (PBT) Chemical Program

    Prior to 1972 when its use was banned, DDT was a commonly used pesticide. Although it is no longer used or produced in the United States, we continue to
    http://www.epa.gov/pbt/pubs/ddt.htm – CachedSimilar
    More results from www.epa.gov »

  5. News results for ddt


    The Associated Press
    EPA plans hearings on DDT deposit off SoCal coast‎ – 1 day ago

    “We have the worst DDT hotspot in the entire US,” he said. “That we’re still stuck with this horrible legacy decades later is awful.” From 1947 to 1971,

    The Associated Press231 related articles »

  6. What’s This?

    ATSDR – ToxFAQs™: DDT, DDE, and DDD

    – 2 visits – 10/28/07

    Sep 11, 2007 Exposure to DDT, DDE, and DDD occurs mostly from eating foods containing small amounts of these compounds, particularly meat,
    http://www.atsdr.cdc.gov/tfacts35.htmlCachedSimilar

  7. EPA plan targets vast DDT deposit off Calif. coast – Yahoo! News

    A plan to cap a vast, long-neglected deposit of the pesticide DDT on the ocean floor off Southern California got its first public airing Tuesday — nearly
    news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20090623/ap_on_re_us/us_ocean_ddtSimilar

  8. Silent spring – Google Books Result

    by Rachel Carson, Edward O. Wilson – 2002 – Nature – 378 pages
    Even if she had not inspired a generation of activists, Carson would prevail as one of the greatest nature writers in American letters” (Peter Matthiessen,…
    books.google.com/books?isbn=0618249060

  9. What’s This?

    Junkscience.com — 100 things you should know about DDT

    – 7 visits – 6/15/08

    Rachel Carson sounded the initial alarm against DDT, but represented the science of DDT The use of DDT under the regulations involved here do not have a
    http://www.junkscience.com/ddtfaq.html – CachedSimilar

  10. DDT : An Introduction

    Not many of us, though, are aware of what DDT is and how it works. This module is here to hopefully give you some insight into the science behind this
    http://www.chem.duke.edu/~jds/cruise_chem/pest/pest1.htmlCachedSimilar

No crank science until #9 in the search. Compare it to Bing:

  • · Cached page
  • The third entry goes to a wrestling maneuver, the fifth entry is the biggest crank science site.  The ninth entry plunges back into crank science at its worst.   This is much improved since I tried it last night and got nothing but crank science (Bing is improving quickly).

    Note: Vaibhav has a post comparing Bing to Google, as he notes in comments.  You may want to check that out, too.  He’s sticking with Bing as default, though he finds Google serves his needs better.  Go figure.


    New blog from the Texas Historical Commission

    June 8, 2009

    Texas Parlor notes that the Texas Historical Commission has gotten into the blog business, with a blog called See the Sites.

    New logo and slogan for the Texas Historical Commission

    New logo and slogan for the Texas Historical Commission

    A lot of photos from the sites the Historical Commission operates, news of special events, and links to the Commission’s sites’ websites.  As yet there are not any substantive historical analyses.

    The new blog accompanies a redesign of the Texas Historical Commission’s website, and the creation of a new logo for the agency, with a new slogan.

    The new website makes navigation a good bit easier, to get to information about cemeteries, or the LaSalle Projects, Texas’s remarkable collection of county courthouses, Civil War monuments, or any of a number of other categories.

    Historians begin to make the internet a real tool for education and learning, and the practice of history recording.

    Tip of the old scrub brush to Will’s Texas Parlor, a site every Texas history teacher should have bookmarked, and should visit often.


    California unemployment map, for economics classrooms

    March 20, 2009

    The Sacramento Bee, one of America’s great newspapers which we hope can stay in business through these tough times, today put up a map of California unemployment, county by county.  The map shows unemployment changes over the past year with an interactive slide that makes it great for classroom use in economics, but makes it impossible for me to embed here (it’s in Adobe Flash).

    California’s unemployment is at about 11% statewide.  Colusa County’s unemployment is 26.6%.  Two counties away, in Marin County, it’s only 6.8%

    California economics classes can use their knowledge of agriculture and industry in the state to make educated guesses about what is going on in each county.  Surely there are uses the rest of us can find.  Colusa and Imperial Counties are two of the hardest hit — with the internet, can your students tell what that is going to mean for prices on fresh produce and processed foods?

    This is where computers and the internet step out ahead in the education tilts, with tools like this interactive map.  Thank you, SacBee.  Can you give teachers a download?

    Another unemployment map, national, for December 2008, The Swordpress

    Another unemployment map, national, for December 2008, The Swordpress


    Obama hoaxers crawl out of the woodwork, onto the internet

    August 31, 2008

     

    Dennis at Thinking in a Marrow Bone — not an Obama supporter, mind you — posted a conversation he had with a guy who posted a hoaxed photo of Barack Obama, purporting to show him holding a landline telephone upside down.

    This is the hoax photo

    Dennis called him on the hoax.  After a few rounds of weak defense, and then moral waffling of significant proportion, the hoaxer deleted the comments from his blog.  Dennis preserved the conversation at TMB.

    Moral of the story:  Don’t believe much of what you hear or see, without corroboration.  If a claim casts aspersions on someone, and comes on the internet, check it out before granting credence. Thanks to Dennis, an honest guy, for exposing the hoax and preserving the record of it.

    Hoaxers are malicious and will do almost anything to damage Obama, even if it requires bringing down the U.S. and burning the flag.  No wonder George Washington wanted out of this sort of politics.

    Question:  What’s the deal with the clock in the doctored photo?  [Oh – it says “3:00 o’clock”]

    Honor roll:  Bloggers and others who exposed the hoax:

    Dishonor roll, the Little List, bloggers who tried to perpetrate and perpetuate the hoax, or who got suckered themselves:

    Special Consideration:

     


    Trivia and waste of bandwidth – until it saves your kid’s life

    August 31, 2008

    Trivial information and internet communication make for bandwidth-wasting and brain-numbing exchanges — friendly, maybe, but your spouse will consider filing papers.

    Until it saves your kid’s life with a dramatic diagnosis of a deadly disease across an ocean.

    Look at the BBC report on the toddler in Florida whose life was saved by a transatlantic, e-mail suggested diagnosis.  Print story from BBC, here.

    A toddler in Florida has been diagnosed with cancer after a Manchester woman saw early warning signs in a picture.

    Madeleine Robb, from Stretford, who has never met her pen pal, spotted a shadow behind one of Rowan Santos’s eyes on pictures from her first birthday.

    She then e-mailed her mother Megan advising her to get medical help.

    The toddler was diagnosed with an aggressive form of cancer – Retinoblastoma – and underwent an operation and is having chemotherapy.

    The two mothers became friends on an internet messageboard after their children were born on the same day.

    But when Mrs Robb saw the pictures she said she knew something was not right.

    Tip of the old scrub brush to Moments in Time.

    [FireFox 3 doesn’t support the old video capture of VodPod; my apologies for sending you to the video, though sending someone to a BBC site is probably a great act of education.]


    And now, the Nigerian scam investigation scam

    August 22, 2008

    A few months ago I posted about a guy who issued a spectacular reply to someone trying the old Nigerian scam on him.

    Yesterday that post got this comment:

    Levy Says:
    August 22, 2008 at 1:56 am edit

    I have found good service for check nigerian. It’s
    http://www.nigerianscamcheck.com

    Go check that site out. If it’s not a scam itself, it should be.  Just what you were looking for, a “good service for check nigerian.”

    Especially note the certificate from the “Global School of Detectives,” the membership in “World Association of Detectives” (yes: W.A.D.), and the certificate from the California Board of Collections and Investigatives Services (P.I.s in California now are licensed by the much newer Bureau of Security and Investigative Services). (See the images of the certificates below.)

    If you ever post again, Levy, I swear I’ll send your name and address to both the Latter-day Saints and Jehovah’s Witnesses.


    Not 1207468165327

    April 8, 2008

    The hottest post on WordPress is a non-post at Fallout 3 a Post-Nuclear Blog.  Go figure.

    It’s only a number:  1207468165327. 

    If you click to the post, you get a note apologizing, but telling you you’re looking for something that isn’t there.

    Is P. Z. Myers right, that popularity on a blog generates more popularity?  Or is that number significant to someone, somewhere — to many someones?

    A magic code to generate traffic, perhaps?  Ah, the Mysteries of the Intertubes, as Sen. Ted Stevens would say.

     


    Debunking the Nigerian scam, with grace and compassion

    March 30, 2008

    This person should be a diplomat; when I am a fool, I hope someone will puncture my balloon with as much wit, grace and caring.

    Oh, yeah — it’s another story about librarians, wouldn’t you know?


    Student project: Photography + cartography + internet

    December 6, 2007

    Ignoble Gases nicely describes the mashup between on-line mapping services and digital photography, with a bit of blogging thrown in.

    Mapping services now have the capacity to link photographs of a site with its exact latitude and longitude, or exact address.  Maps of cities can feature links to photos of the site (other than satellite or aerial photos) submitted by readers, and other descriptive material.

    So, geography teachers:  Have your kids mapped out your town and put it on the web to encourage tourism?  Great discussion topics:  What are the advantages of such technologies, and what are the parent-scaring disadvantages, or dangers of them?

    I really cannot do justice to the concepts here — read the article at Ignoble Gases.