Based on a true story — except, not Texas. Not a chainsaw. Not a massacre.

Nota bene: Be sure to see update, here.

First, there was the woman who squealed in class when I mentioned Travis County, the Texas county in which resides Texas’s capital city, Austin. She said later she had thought it was a fictional county. By the way, she asked, was the rest of the “Texas chainsaw massacre” story true, too? (I have never seen any of these movies; I understand the 2003 version was set in Hewitt, Texas, which is a real, small Texas town near Waco, between Dallas and Austin — but not in Travis County. I’m not sure what Travis County has to do with any of the movies.)

Logs awaiting processing at a sawmill in Nacogdoches County, Texas - Ron Billings photo

Victims of a real Texas chainsaw massacre: Victims await “processing” at a sawmill in Nacogdoches County. Photo by Ron Billings, Texas Forest Service.

Since then, in the last couple of weeks I have had at least a dozen requests to teach the history behind the movie, the “true story.” The movies are all highly fictionalized, I note. Perhaps I should plan a day to discuss real Texas murders, and just what fiction is, especially from Hollywood.

According to, one of my favorite debunking sites, there was never a Texas chainsaw massacre. There was a Wisconsin farmer who stole corpses from the local cemetery, and upon whom was based the earlier Alfred Hitchcock movie, Psycho. There was the chainsaw exhibit at Montgomery Ward seen by writer/director Toby Hooper, when he needed inspiration to finish a screen treatment. That’s about it.

But it’s nearing Halloween, and the studios in Hollywood hope to make money.

There are real Texas crimes that would be good fodder for movies, in the hands of intelligent and creative people. One wonders why more movies aren’t done on the real stories.

Historian Kent Biffle has a weekly column on Texas history matters in the Dallas Morning News, for example — and last week he featured a murder mystery from 1847, in which guests at a wedding were served cake laced with arsenic:

No matter how you sliced it, the luxurious dessert served to 60 East Texans in May 1847 was the wedding cake from hell. A few toxic bites sent guests into convulsions. At least 10 died.

Lacking autopsy tests, backwoods folks blamed arsenic poisoning.

The nuptials united a young couple on a Shelby County farm near the Sabine River settlement of East Hamilton, which today is little more than a cemetery where historian Bill O’Neal suspects several cake-eaters lie.

Author O’Neal links the mass poisoning to what he concludes was “Texas’ deadliest feud” in his new book, War in East Texas: Regulators vs. Moderators. Vigilantes organized as “Regulators” to punish suspected outlaws, usually by flogging. Soon enough they traded in their whips and canes for a lynch mob’s nooses and shotguns. Moderators claimed they arose to regulate the Regulators. As usual, in applying folk justice, vigilante leaders tended to target their personal enemies along with real outlaws.

“Four years or so of Regulator-Moderator warfare, along with a lethal aftermath, produced more than 30 deaths – more than 40 if the poisoned victims of the wedding feast are added,” said the Panola College professor O’Neal. He was in Nacogdoches last weekend to describe the Regulator-Moderator insurrection to members of the East Texas Historical Association.

It was full-out range war. One of the leaders of one faction got so good at killing, he thought he’d raise an army and take over Texas. Texas President Sam Houston personally intervened and brought the warring sides to the peace table (shades of the Camp David Accord). Then one was killed in a duel brought about when his mistress exchanged slurs with a physician’s wife.

Texas history is often the stuff of movies. The real stuff would make better movies that a lot of what gets made into movies these days. And for a lot of it, the stories are in the public domain. Fewer writers to pay.

Thomas Hewitt, the Hewitt clan, and the Texas Chainsaw Massacre, are all fictional.

Help others get the facts:

Add to FacebookAdd to NewsvineAdd to DiggAdd to Del.icio.usAdd to StumbleuponAdd to RedditAdd to BlinklistAdd to TwitterAdd to TechnoratiAdd to Furl

Update, October 27, 2012:  Welcome visitors!  For some reason my statistics compiler is not picking up from what site you all are coming, nor who referred you.  Please do me the favor of noting in comments that you read the post, and tell from what site you were referred, or what you were searching for that brought you to this post.  Thank you!

117 Responses to Based on a true story — except, not Texas. Not a chainsaw. Not a massacre.

  1. Ed Darrell says:

    No, the story is not true. It’s fictional.


  2. Jackie says:

    So, true story or not? Great article, though still not convinced


  3. Ed Darrell says:

    Mr. Martinez, see the paragraph above that starts:

    There was a Wisconsin farmer who stole corpses from the local cemetery, and upon whom was based the earlier Alfred Hitchcock movie, Psycho.

    The Wisconsin farmer was Gein. Wisconsin is a long way from Texas. Gein had no Texas family.


  4. I randomly again thought of is Thomas hewit, leather face real. I read leather face was based on a man named ed gein. He is in no way shape or form anything like the movie depict


  5. Ed Darrell says:

    Thank you, Wild Bill.


  6. WildBill says:

    Came from Google bud.


  7. Deborah Macdonald says:

    That was an interesting, little history lesson.


  8. Patricia Cunningham says:

    I did read the article.
    I used Google to refer me to this site.
    I searched Google for ” the Hewitt family murders in Texas between 1969 and 1973.”

    Liked by 1 person

  9. I am on the google website from my dumb smart phone I think but was looking for info about leatherface

    Liked by 1 person

  10. Lisa says:

    I just watched the latest movie: the prequel, I guess? Prequels…ugh

    Liked by 1 person

  11. I searched Google for was Leatherface a real person


  12. Ed Darrell says:

    We are free to believe any fool thing we wish. But this is a case where evidence should be required.

    Where do you think the fictional Thomas Hewitt is? Haven’t authorities got on to him after a dozen movies?


  13. i think thomas hewitt is real yes he will kill again


  14. Ed Darrell says:

    Did you read the story?

    “Texas Chainsaw Massacre” is fiction. There never were any Hewitts.


  15. chae says:

    Are ed gien and thomas brown Hewitt the same ppl.and is thomas leather face Hewitt in a prison in is siad Edwards gien.died in 1984 in a mental institution in confuse.are there two people.and did these murders happen in Texas or Minnesota.


  16. […] Based on a true story — except, not Texas . Not a … – Oct 08, 2006 · Since then, in the last couple of weeks I have had at least a dozen requests to teach the history behind the movie, the “true story.” The movies are …… […]


  17. kiany says:

    SCARYYY lol sike


Please play nice in the Bathtub -- splash no soap in anyone's eyes. While your e-mail will not show with comments, note that it is our policy not to allow false e-mail addresses. Comments with non-working e-mail addresses may be deleted.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: